Really, need you ask? If the chap can’t discern objective analysis from editorial comment, a degree-level education seems highly unlikely. I’d be more inclined to ask for evidence of his 4th grade english comprehension achievements.

I think he wrote that before disqus was added here, in other words he likely won’t see it unless he gets back onto this specific page, I can’t press on his name or anyone else’s on this page which strengthens my point, anyone that’s a part of disqus can have their names clicked on.

Hi Phil,

Are you a Vet yourself? Just interested to know what your credentials are. (As you say – it’s not a good idea to by opinions)

Johann

Hi Phil, I appreciate your sentiments. This is an open forum so if you’re able to add factual points then please do so for the benefit of others. I’d be especially keen to hear why you believe changing diet is a bad thing, or whether you’re aware how much coverage of diet and nutrition there is on a veterinary course (BVSc)?

The reviews are based on ingredients and guaranteed analysis and are written as a starting point to provoke thought and guidance. They’re not based on the opinion or influence of consumers or manufacturers.

Hi Nicole, both are good foods. I often recommend mixing a couple of foods to achieve a more balance diet, so yes you could do that too.