Comments on: Cat Food Reviews in America https://www.petfoodjudge.com/cat-food-reviews/ Dog food reviews / Cat food reviews Tue, 09 Sep 2025 12:16:29 +0000 hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=6.9.4 By: David D'Angelo https://www.petfoodjudge.com/cat-food-reviews/#comment-45943 Sat, 22 Feb 2025 13:37:36 +0000 https://www.petfoodjudge.com/?p=34965#comment-45943 In reply to Tasha.

Hi Tasha, I see the most common cause of urinary problems in cats to be dry food in general, particularly those made of cereal grains – cats are carnivores who shouldn’t have cereals in their diet. Hill’s C/D dry is made from corn, wheat, and rice along with some chicken, which really doesn’t sound species appropriate to me even if they add a little DL-Methionine and potassium citrate to dilute crystals.

Moisture is so important for cats – more so if they’re already suffering urinary issues. Moisture dilutes the urine and helps reduce crystals forming, and dry food is counter-productive in this respect.

If your vet has told you Frontier Pets (essentially raw prey ingredients your cat would instinctively eat) is causing crystals, then ask why they would recommend you feed your cat a dry processed food made of cereals to fix the problem in your pet carnivore.

A better solution might be to remove the dry and see if your cat’s health improves. Even the Hill’s wet foods are more species appropriate. Or, even if you want to continue with the dry, would you consider giving your cat a raw chicken neck once a day or every other day?

]]>
By: Tasha https://www.petfoodjudge.com/cat-food-reviews/#comment-45921 Fri, 21 Feb 2025 13:14:32 +0000 https://www.petfoodjudge.com/?p=34965#comment-45921 In reply to David D’Angelo.

Hi David,

What do you recommend for cat with previous utis and a blockage? I was recommended Hills CD and had him on that for a few months and had another uti. I switched to frontier pets lamb and fish while still feeding some hills. Cat had a urine test today and had crystals. The vet said it was the frontier pets’ food and suggested I stop feeding the frontier pets and only feed the Hills..

]]>
By: David D'Angelo https://www.petfoodjudge.com/cat-food-reviews/#comment-41425 Sat, 27 Jul 2026 13:54:38 +0000 https://www.petfoodjudge.com/?p=34965#comment-41425 In reply to Jose.

Hi Jose, lots of options, but for what reason do you need a high fibre/controlled calcium dog food?

]]>
By: David D'Angelo https://www.petfoodjudge.com/cat-food-reviews/#comment-41418 Sat, 27 Jul 2026 13:39:50 +0000 https://www.petfoodjudge.com/?p=34965#comment-41418 In reply to Bec.

Hi Bec, Tiki Cat looks pretty good from a formula perspective. Here’s a review.

]]>
By: Jose https://www.petfoodjudge.com/cat-food-reviews/#comment-40379 Fri, 26 Apr 2026 06:01:12 +0000 https://www.petfoodjudge.com/?p=34965#comment-40379 What would be an alternative to Hills WD (high fibre and controlled calcium levels), but with a much better ingredient list?
Thank you.

]]>
By: Pet Food Judge (America) https://www.petfoodjudge.com/cat-food-reviews/#comment-38533 Mon, 27 Nov 2023 12:10:38 +0000 https://www.petfoodjudge.com/?p=34965#comment-38533 In reply to kim.

Hi Kim, when a kitten (or pup) has been raised on one (or two) brands of pet food, it’s very common to see some digestive upset when you change the food. For this reason it’s worth changing gradually, so going from a bit of the new food to more of the new food over a couple of weeks. Moving forward, feeding your kitten a variety should stop them suffering digestive upset over the long term.

Feeding a mix of wet/dry/fresh/raw is all good in my opinion, and better than feeding a completely dry or completely wet diet.

As for brands I try not to make specific recommendations, but any of the best rated cat food page should be a good start.

]]>
By: kim https://www.petfoodjudge.com/cat-food-reviews/#comment-38511 Sat, 25 Nov 2023 01:30:29 +0000 https://www.petfoodjudge.com/?p=34965#comment-38511 Hi!,

Myself and my 3 children are getting a kitten in a few weeks and we are super excited! from what I know the kitten is being fed a combination of Leaps and Bounds cat food and Fussy cat food (cant say which one is wet or dry though) both of which don’t seem to have very good reviews that I read above. I don’t want to cause any upset to the kitty’s tummy so I’m assuming I will need to continue with those foods and slowly introduce something else, also something I’m not sure of lol!

I have looked at quite a few options and taking into consideration the financial side of it and availability, I landed on Black Hawk kitten food, I will be using a combination of wet and dry food.

Any feedback/advice would be greatly appreciated!
Thanks for your time 🙂
Kim.

]]>
By: CP https://www.petfoodjudge.com/cat-food-reviews/#comment-36895 Tue, 18 Jul 2023 02:57:02 +0000 https://www.petfoodjudge.com/?p=34965#comment-36895 Hi, I can’t see Pretty Wild here, sold in Woolies. Woolies website for the wet cat food says Made in China yet no mention of this on the packaging. I emailed Pretty Wild asking where the food is made but have had no response after emailing them twice, so buyer beware.

]]>
By: Pet Food Judge (America) https://www.petfoodjudge.com/cat-food-reviews/#comment-36611 Tue, 20 Jun 2023 07:18:28 +0000 https://www.petfoodjudge.com/?p=34965#comment-36611 In reply to Callie.

Hi Callie, generally I think too much of anything is a bad idea, and the concerns with too much fish include mercury and other toxicity. Raw fish can cause thiamine deficiency when fed in excess, which although isn’t relevant to kibble is still a good example of why anything in excess can be bad.

Native cats would catch small prey, but also scavenge prey caught by large predators. You make a really good point though. I expect the only reason you don’t get “mouse”, “lizard”, or “gecko” cat foods is because consumers wouldn’t buy them. We humanise our pets which means most consumers would prefer to feed what we eat, so that’s what pet food manufacturers target.

]]>
By: Callie https://www.petfoodjudge.com/cat-food-reviews/#comment-36607 Tue, 20 Jun 2023 05:30:53 +0000 https://www.petfoodjudge.com/?p=34965#comment-36607 Hi, I love your reviews but in one of them you mentioned that you shouldn’t just feed fish-based food to cats because it’s not a natural food source for them… and you should alternate it with other proteins. Can you please explain this a bit more?
Of course it’s not appropriate to feed your cat fish that was intended for consumption by human (eg canned tuna), but the better pet foods include other ingredients that make it more nutritionally balanced for cats. I also think fish is no less “natural” than beef, lamb, goat etc (never seen a cat stalking a herd animal for dinner… unless it’s a big cat like tiger etc). Unless someone develops a mouse, lizard, gecko etc based cat food, none of the proteins on the market are really what a cat would eat in the wild…

]]>