Comments on: Holistic Select Grain Free Dog Food Review https://www.petfoodjudge.com/holistic-select-grain-free-dog-food-review/ Dog food reviews / Cat food reviews Tue, 02 Sep 2025 15:18:17 +0000 hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=6.9.4 By: Pet Food Judge (America) https://www.petfoodjudge.com/holistic-select-grain-free-dog-food-review/#comment-39022 Thu, 11 Jan 2026 17:58:33 +0000 https://www.petfoodjudge.com/?p=1378#comment-39022 In reply to Justine.

Hi Justine, it’s taken me a while to respond – sorry. My best advice would be to err on the side of caution and return the bag to the place of purchase. Mould can and does happen to many brands and can occur anywhere through manufacture, transport, or at a retailer warehouse.

]]>
By: Justine https://www.petfoodjudge.com/holistic-select-grain-free-dog-food-review/#comment-38743 Tue, 19 Dec 2023 00:00:01 +0000 https://www.petfoodjudge.com/?p=1378#comment-38743 I’ve just bought a new bag of the holistic select grain free adult/puppy salmon 10kg and it is extremely dusty and smells weird. We have bought this exact bag previously at the beginning of the year and it did not look like this. I’m terrified this is mould because this is exactly how the meals for mutts looked and our dogs are still recovering from that many months later. No phone number to constant the company extremely upset and concerned.

]]>
By: Veronika https://www.petfoodjudge.com/holistic-select-grain-free-dog-food-review/#comment-13591 Wed, 20 Sep 2017 02:27:00 +0000 https://www.petfoodjudge.com/?p=1378#comment-13591 In reply to caroline.

It’ll be hard to find something else for Patch there is a lot he can’t have I think what’s best is to try and keep the kibble to a minimum and feed as much fresh whole foods as you possibly can.

I’ve gone this route with Rusty.

]]>
By: caroline https://www.petfoodjudge.com/holistic-select-grain-free-dog-food-review/#comment-13590 Wed, 20 Sep 2017 00:23:00 +0000 https://www.petfoodjudge.com/?p=1378#comment-13590 In reply to Susan.

Hi Susan , Thanks for the Clean Label link, I had a look & TOTW only got 1 star that’s looks bad & Canidae scored quite good.
I know you use TOTW for Patch will you change to something else now.
I think American food would be quite a lot cleaner for our pets

]]>
By: Kat https://www.petfoodjudge.com/holistic-select-grain-free-dog-food-review/#comment-13589 Tue, 19 Sep 2017 23:53:00 +0000 https://www.petfoodjudge.com/?p=1378#comment-13589 In reply to Susan.

Thankyou so much – will try get some today, you have a wealth of knowledge that has just made my pups and my life so much easier and safer lol – thanks 🙂

]]>
By: Susan https://www.petfoodjudge.com/holistic-select-grain-free-dog-food-review/#comment-13588 Tue, 19 Sep 2017 22:16:00 +0000 https://www.petfoodjudge.com/?p=1378#comment-13588 In reply to Kat.

HI Kat, have a look at Clean Label Project they test American pet foods link below Holistic select has tested very high for toxcins, I wonder my my IBD boy became unwell after eating Holistic Select-Salmon, Earthborn Holistic-Ocean Fusion, Wellness-Whitefish, & TOTW-Salmon all these American dog foods rated very high with Toxins click on the “Brand Report Card” link on my link on the CLP site, . Look at Meals For Mutts, Stay Loyal, Ivory Coat American made kibble or feeding a raw diet your dog will be healthier eating a raw diet or feed kibble for 1 meal & raw for his other meal & bath your pup in “Malaseb” medicated shampoo twice a week or weekly so you wash off any allergens on his skin, Malaseb shampoo is for yeasty itchy skin & allergies, your dog probably has environment allergies & also could have a food sensitivities that causes yeasty skin, Sudocrem is excellent its in the baby section the Sudocrem acts as a barrier & protects the skin form allergens I apply cream before Patch goes on walks & I also use the Huggie Baby Wipes, Coconut Oil wipes to wipe off the allergens on his skin after being outside.. http://www.cleanlabelproject.org/pet-food-study-2-0/

]]>
By: Kat https://www.petfoodjudge.com/holistic-select-grain-free-dog-food-review/#comment-13587 Tue, 19 Sep 2017 14:09:00 +0000 https://www.petfoodjudge.com/?p=1378#comment-13587 In reply to Pet Food Judge.

Ah awesome thank you 🙂 (lol just realised I quoted one of your FAQ lol) – my pup is having some allergies (yeast ear infections and papules/red skin/itchiness) and we’re starting at the food end of the scale, I was recommended this brand in the adult/puppy poultry/grain free product to start with – we couldn’t find any other puppy mix that was poultry free…. I think you know your stuff so any recommendations appreciated 🙂

]]>
By: Pet Food Judge https://www.petfoodjudge.com/holistic-select-grain-free-dog-food-review/#comment-13586 Tue, 19 Sep 2017 13:22:00 +0000 https://www.petfoodjudge.com/?p=1378#comment-13586 In reply to Kat.

Hi Kat, I’m pretty sure no major brand imports are irradiated these days.

An overseas dog food manufacturer requires an inspection of their facility in order to import food to America. They can opt out of this requirement by having food irradiated on import. For this reason I would be wary of imports from small manufacturers, but commercial brands such as this should not be irradiated.

]]>
By: Kat https://www.petfoodjudge.com/holistic-select-grain-free-dog-food-review/#comment-13585 Tue, 19 Sep 2017 12:54:00 +0000 https://www.petfoodjudge.com/?p=1378#comment-13585 With this product being made in USA, what treatment does it go through to be available in America? I have heard a lot of pet products go through irradiation to pass quarantine standards but the consequences of this has resulted in cat food banned from being imported due to severe neurological impairment and fatales. (guessing being a smaller animal impacts more??) The company does not have to acknowledge what process they used to get the product into America – Does anyone know the answer? (I have a puppy with allergies and this appears the only product available to us with not poultry…)

]]>
By: Susan https://www.petfoodjudge.com/holistic-select-grain-free-dog-food-review/#comment-12658 Mon, 19 Dec 2016 09:38:00 +0000 https://www.petfoodjudge.com/?p=1378#comment-12658 In reply to Lisa.

Hi the Omega-3 in the “Holistic Select” Adult/Puppy Salmon, Anchovy & Sardine grain free formula is quiet good, Omega-3=150% & Omega-6 = 200%. that’s pretty good, always read the omega 3 & 6, Omega-3 should be 1/2 of what the Omega-6% is…..A lot of kibbles are very high in Omega-6 & very low in Omega-3 & are not balanced properly causing skin problems & inflammatory health problems,

]]>