Comments on: Kirkland Signature Nature’s Domain Cat Food Review https://www.petfoodjudge.com/kirkland-cat-food-review/ Dog food reviews / Cat food reviews Wed, 29 Apr 2026 12:18:21 +0000 hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=6.9.4 By: Marco https://www.petfoodjudge.com/kirkland-cat-food-review/#comment-62021 Wed, 29 Apr 2026 12:18:21 +0000 https://www.petfoodjudge.com/?p=2152#comment-62021 It seems like the reviews for the Kirkland/Costco brands are reasonably old now, any chance of getting them updated to see if they are still near as good as they used to be?

]]>
By: Rose Wangler https://www.petfoodjudge.com/kirkland-cat-food-review/#comment-38569 Fri, 01 Dec 2023 03:25:47 +0000 https://www.petfoodjudge.com/?p=2152#comment-38569 In reply to Sonia Leyner.

Yes, Sonia, use the Kirkland maintenance cat chicken and rice formula. I have been using this to feed homeless cats for years and they do very well on it. I supplement it once or twice a week by buying cans of cheap mackerel at WinCo food or getting them a rotisserie chicken from costco. It’s only fault is being just a tiny bit low in protein but you can easily fix that by mixing in some of these meats once in awhile. They do really well on this, it doesn’t kill them like the cheap crap on the bottom shelf at Walmart.

]]>
By: Edanna https://www.petfoodjudge.com/kirkland-cat-food-review/#comment-32505 Fri, 06 Nov 2020 09:05:38 +0000 https://www.petfoodjudge.com/?p=2152#comment-32505 In reply to Sonia Leyner.

Hi there what your doing is wonderful but indeed caring for so many souls is never a cheap task and as much as you’d love to feed them species appropriate it isn’t always that easy.

I have gone onto the website and I have checked the food out, it is perfect and very cheap for the ingredients, I highly recommend it on that basis alone, the analysis protein/fat etc is also very good. This food is very well thought out and deserves an oscar for those ingredients at that price point wow!

Aldi Natural Elements cans are very good, I’m just not sure they have cat versions, however since taurine is in the kibble, the cans don’t really require it, you can actually always supplement it if you feel it necessary.

You can get a 100g bag for $16 and all you need is a pinch per cat, would last forever even with 120+ lol. But their taurine needs I think are rather low and as long as they eat the kibble they’ll get what they need.

I looked it up but most have 0.12% and that’s enough and this one is 0.1%, but it is added and I would think that despite it looking lower that they are conforming to the AAFCO standards.

]]>
By: Sonia Leyner https://www.petfoodjudge.com/kirkland-cat-food-review/#comment-32487 Fri, 06 Nov 2020 05:10:27 +0000 https://www.petfoodjudge.com/?p=2152#comment-32487 Hi, I was wondering how the Maintenance cat food from Costco compares? It costs about the same but the bag is 3kg more. It does list rice as the third and fourth ingredients, but on the face of it the nutritional figures are almost the same as the one you’ve reviewed above. We are a very small group of volunteers looking after 120+ cats in a daily basis and have been using the aldi premium food thinking it was better than their cheap crap until I saw your review of it and was horrified to find that as you’ve correctly put it “it’s crap in a fancy bag”. I’m trying to find the cheapest possible option obviously, but for food that is worth while feeding them. Many people laugh and say “they’re just street cats!” But of course to us they are family and it’s note important than even with house cats to feed them the correct food in order to fend off I’ll health to which they’re so much more prone than the average pet cat. If you have any suggestions for a good and inexpensive wet food I’d love to hear that also. We feed them raw (human grade) meat/mince/ chicken at least twice per week, but the rest of the time they’ve been getting certain kinds of cans (only certain “colours” as we’re aware some of them are just awful) from aldi which were described by a Choice review as fairly good for them.

]]>
By: Heide-Marie Chan https://www.petfoodjudge.com/kirkland-cat-food-review/#comment-32519 Sun, 03 Nov 2019 10:01:42 +0000 https://www.petfoodjudge.com/?p=2152#comment-32519 Would like to know what the Calcium to Protein ratio is for each of these products. Best way to know how good they are.

]]>
By: Doreen McCann https://www.petfoodjudge.com/kirkland-cat-food-review/#comment-12720 Thu, 12 Jan 2017 04:23:00 +0000 https://www.petfoodjudge.com/?p=2152#comment-12720 In reply to disqus_qkJ58drn2W.

Did you know that a combo of dry food mixed with wet food makes a better digestible diet?
Add canned food to the quantity of kibble you want to serve your cat. Mix them well. Try a ratio of 20% wet food to 80% dry for each meal. Even better= add a bit of water to some canned food and lightly warm in microwave. Make a mixture the consistency of a thick gravy and mix onto your kibble. Then serve this in a non-porous dish (or flattened bowl) = this is a great way to add moisture and a bit more flavor to your cats meal without changing the kibble base. Pate or ground canned food makes the better choice to mix in with the kibble.

]]>
By: Doreen McCann https://www.petfoodjudge.com/kirkland-cat-food-review/#comment-12719 Thu, 12 Jan 2017 04:14:00 +0000 https://www.petfoodjudge.com/?p=2152#comment-12719 In reply to Amateria.

Absolutely! Always add more moisture to your cats meal! One of my methods is to hot-soak some of this kibble (Use half cup of dry kibble in steel bowl, add hot water, and cover). When cooled down, feed about 50/50 soaked kibble to dry kibble of an appropriate serving along with a few tablespoons of warmed canned food and mix well. This is my cats’ supper meal and it ensures they are getting an appropriate amount of moisture into their diet. It is called “scheduled” feeding and a lot better than free-feeding dry — which is hard on your cats kidneys.

]]>
By: Amateria https://www.petfoodjudge.com/kirkland-cat-food-review/#comment-12354 Wed, 14 Sep 2016 13:52:00 +0000 https://www.petfoodjudge.com/?p=2152#comment-12354 In reply to disqus_qkJ58drn2W.

Some specific ingredients have been known to make it worse, your cats could of already had the problem, just hid it really well from you as that’s what pets usually tend to do.

You should also be adding either water to the kibble or a canned food as cats don’t drink very much water, this will help to lower the chance of getting cystitis, doesn’t mean it will remove the chance completely though.

]]>
By: disqus_qkJ58drn2W https://www.petfoodjudge.com/kirkland-cat-food-review/#comment-12352 Wed, 14 Sep 2016 01:43:00 +0000 https://www.petfoodjudge.com/?p=2152#comment-12352 We bought this food based on this review and since feeding to our two cats one has developed occasional cystitis symptoms. Vet checks were done and they could not find an underlying cause, the only lifestyle change my cat had experienced was the swapping of dry food products. Since this food has a good ingredient list compared to other brands I’m at a loss as to why it would cause these problems.

]]>