Hi Tess, the PREY range is limited ingredient, but from looking at the ingredients list I can see why it looks longer! Most of it amounts to the vitamin and mineral inclusions, whereas the main ingredients are more limited than a regular cat food formula. If that makes sense?

I’ve just added an out-of-10 rating, but if your cat isn’t suffering dietary intolerances then either or with the Taste of the Wild formulas. Weruva wet food is great in the mix, and I always consider variety a good thing.

Hi Johanna, I consider chicken fat a much better alternative to sunflower oil for cats as carnivores. If your cat isn’t sensitive to chicken then I wouldn’t consider it problematic in that sense, and I find cats more sensitive to grains (which they shouldn’t be eating much of anyway).

If you want samples ask the companies making the foods. Most don’t do samples, but there’s still a few that continue to do it. Simply email them asking if they do it and if they do provide your address to them.

If you don’t want them knowing your address than your going to have trouble getting samples.

A decent cat food would mimic the gut contents of prey with small amounts of fruits and vegetables, so it’s not a bad thing seeing something like cranberry in a cat food. I have more concerns when a cat food has non-meat ingredients making up the bulk of the formula, especially with excessive starch or cereal grains, which sadly sums up most commercial cat foods.